TLI ToolkitTorchlight: Infinite companionDownload

Guide · SS14 Tartarus

Confusion Cards

Which Confusion Cards to take on the Netherrealm stage: what each adds, what it is worth in FE, and which tiers are data and which are opinion.

← All guides

Choose for this map, not for a letter tier ↓

Also called: Chaos Cards

Chaos Cards, Chaos Invasion, Mystery Cards, Confusion Card Library, Netherrealm cards, 混乱卡, 迷惑卡

Last checked against SS14 Tartarus · 10 min read · updated

In TLI Toolkit: Guides page, with live prices

Choose for this map, not for a letter tier

  1. Read the full card variant, strength and required gameplay before comparing rewards. The list below is a November 10 price-based reference, not a measured current income ranking. “Data” means the stated drop amount can be valued under those inputs; it does not certify the tier or future sale.

  2. Worked draft, 2026-11-15: suppose you can choose a Beacon variant whose displayed strength adds 1–2 Beacons, a Mist reward card, or a global quantity card. Your planned stage has no Mist gameplay. Exclude the Mist card from this reward comparison; its valuable item does not help when the required content is absent.

  3. For a synthetic current quote of 10 FE per Beacon, the 1–2 additional Beacons are worth 8.75–17.5 FE after the 12.5% sale tax if sold. At an alternative quote of 2 FE the range is 1.75–3.5 FE. These are invented prices for the exercise, not current listings. Keeping the Beacon for entry avoids a sale, but do not count both sale proceeds and an avoided purchase.

  4. The global quantity card is an alternative, not automatically worse. You need the applicable quantity rules and the value of affected drops to compare it numerically; multiplying all profit by the printed percentage is not valid. If those inputs are unknown, take the predictable compatible reward or test the alternative in an affordable controlled batch. Record which strength you actually used.

Glacial Abyss Beacon Use 5 FE net as a practice cutoff for this Beacon option. At the 10 FE quote, even one Beacon clears it. At 2 FE, even two fall short. A compatible alternative with evidence for at least 5 FE net would beat the second case. Use the Beacon type you actually expect to sell when you check the quote.

What a Confusion Card does

On the Netherrealm board each stage can carry a Confusion Card. Its modifier is on the stage while it is played, and no item is spent for it. The tlidb card library lists about 200 cards in some 30 families, most of them with 2 to 3 strengths that unlock with the Timemark. This page ranks the cards by what they add to a map’s income.

Data and Opinion. Tiers marked Data rest on drop sizes and prices. Tiers marked Opinion are judgement calls. No public source ranks these cards, and the app’s own run history has too few runs per card to rank them. Checked on 2026-11-10 against tlidb.com, the price feed, TapTap, mmoexp and a general web search; no Confusion Card tier list was found.

How to choose

  • Look at the drop, then its price. A card that adds a Deep Space Beacon (about 20 FE each) or an Ultimate Ember (about 16 FE) pays for itself many times over. A card that adds Netherrealm Resonance, Energy Cores or Flame Sand adds a few tenths of an FE at best.
  • Multipliers are next. +% Drop Quantity multiplies everything the map drops, so it is worth more the better your map already is. Take global Drop Quantity over a mini-game card unless you run that mini-game every map. Opinion
  • Gameplay cards only matter when that gameplay is in the stage. A Whispering Mist or Aeterna card does nothing on a stage without that content.
  • Beacons and Ultimate Embers first. At the dated prices below these are convenient examples of valuable added drops. Other cards can matter too; compatibility, strength and your actual setup decide the comparison.
  • Mystery Chests (Arrogance). A Season 13 farming guide ranks extra Mystery Chests (4 to 6) as excellent, second only to extra copies of all Confusion Cards. It was written for SS13; cards were retuned in SS14.
  • Do not take a card for a drop that sells for under 1 FE a piece (Netherrealm Resonance, Energy Cores, Flame Sand, Precious Embers) unless nothing else is on offer.
  • Cards that add monsters (Scornful, Contemptuous, Despicable) raise kills and time per map together. Whether that pays depends on your clear speed. Opinion Untested.

The tier list

Names and effects are as the client and tlidb show them, in English. Gameplay cards are marked with the gameplay they need. The Basis column says whether the tier follows from numbers (Data) or is a judgement (Opinion).

Full card catalog and ratings
S: take these first
CardBasisWhy
Hypocritical – BeaconDataBosses drop 0-1, 1-2 or 2-4 additional Beacons: 10 to 60 FE a map at the Beacon price, on average.
Hypocritical – EmberDataBosses drop additional Embers. Per the app’s modifier text, its strongest strength adds an Ultimate Ember (about 16 FE).
Shivering – Whispering Mist (needs Whispering Mist)DataBosses have a 100% chance to drop 1 additional Mist Essence (about 70 FE).
Indolent – Aeterna (needs Aeterna)DataBosses have a 100% chance to drop 1 additional Queen’s Wick (27 to 164 FE by kind).
A: strong
CardBasisWhy
FrivolousOpinion+20% or +30% Drop Quantity on everything. Always useful, never a jackpot.
ArroganceOpinion4-6 Mystery Chests in the stage. Rated highly for Residents’ Eye farming in SS13 (mmoexp).
Mad – Might (needs God of Might)DataEmbers have a 3% chance to become Ultimate Embers: 0.5 FE per Ember dropped. Good only if the trial gives you many Embers.
Willful – Might (needs God of Might)Opinion+100% additional Drop Quantity during the trial.
Cunning – Hunting (needs Goddess of Hunting)OpinionFinal Boss Hunting Rewards have a 36% or 54% chance to drop 1 additional Compass.
CovetDataTwo groups of Malice Incarnation Disciples have a 15% chance to drop 1 Transcendence Wedge. Depends on the wedge grade.
StingyOpinionBosses drop 0-2, 1-2 or 2-4 additional Legendary gear pieces. Worth what your filter keeps.
Malice (Cube)OpinionBosses drop 0-2 or 1-2 additional Divinity Slates.
B: fine when nothing better is offered
CardBasisWhy
RashOpinion+30% or +45% Drop Rarity.
JealousOpinion+30% or +50% additional Gear Drop Quantity.
NarrowOpinion+20% or +30% additional Compass Drop Quantity.
Mania – Might / Conservative – MachineOpinion+10% to +15% Drop Quantity inside their trial.
Crafty – HuntingOpinion11%, 16% or 32% chance of a Plane Watcher Chest when the Final Boss dies.
ImpulsiveOpinionRare monsters gain an affix and +80% Drop Rarity.
Hypocritical – Fluorescence, MelancholyOpinionMore Fluorescent Memories (extra drop, or a 20% to 30% replication).
Persuasive – Arcana, Bewitching – ArcanaOpinionBetter Notes of Arcana. Worth it only if you spend them.
Piteous, DisheartenedOpinionStarshards replicate (40%, or 100% with a Giantism boss).
DistressedDataOne group of Queen’s Disciples that may drop Beacons. A chance at a 20 FE item, size unknown.
C: gameplay bonuses and monster cards
CardBasisWhy
Grief, Hushed, Extravagant, Simple, Punitive, Oppressive, Restrained, Insane and the other “+x% Drop Quantity for one gameplay” cardsOpinionThey only raise the rewards of one mini-game. Good if you do it every map.
Scornful, Contemptuous, DespicableOpinionMore monsters means more kills and more time.
Brutal – War, Berserk – WarOpinionMore War Shrine stacks and Berserkers. The strongest Berserk strength has an 8% chance of a Beacon per Berserker.
Cold, Severe, Harsh – The Frozen CanvasDataSnowpaper Fragments sell for 0.05 FE; the cards matter only inside Frozen Canvas.
Abashed, Uptight – SandlordOpinionOasis Coins and Sand Pirates: feeds the Oasis, not FE.
Disgraceful, Humiliated, Resentful, Remorseful, Heretical – Dark SurgeOpinionBetter Eruption rewards. Aemberon Core sells for 0.01 FE.
D: skip
CardBasisWhy
Hypocritical – Echo, DispiritedDataNetherrealm Resonance, 0.09 FE each: the 20-28 of Dispirited is 2 to 3 FE and also hastens the boss.
Hypocritical – Core, BewilderedDataEnergy Cores at 0.04 FE: 5-7 of them are 0.2 FE.
Hypocritical – Fuel, HesitateDataFlame Sand is worth 0.0002 FE.
Depressed, ReluctantDataPrecious Embers sell for 0.05 FE; a 3% or 7% chance of one is nothing.
Hopeless – NightmareOpinionLowers the chance to enter a Nightmare, which is what the Nightmare cards’ rewards need.

What the drops are worth

Historical measurements and price inputs
What the drops the cards add sell for (price feed, 2026-11-10, rounded)
DropAbout, FE eachAdded by
Deep Space Beacon20Hypocritical – Beacon, Distressed, Berserk – War
Ultimate Ember16Hypocritical – Ember (top strength), Mad – Might
Mist Essence70Shivering – Whispering Mist
Queen’s Wick (Imprisoned, Pursuit, Revenge)27 to 164Indolent – Aeterna
Unifying Wedge / Transcendence Wedge (Legendary)30 / 5Covet
Matchless Ember0.3Hypocritical – Ember (middle strength)
Netherrealm Resonance0.09Hypocritical – Echo, Dispirited
Precious Ember0.05Depressed
Snowpaper Fragment0.05Cold – The Frozen Canvas
Energy Core0.04Hypocritical – Core, Bewildered
Flame Sand0.0002Hypocritical – Fuel
Prices move: these tiers use the fixed November 10 inputs, including a Beacon at about 20 FE. Revalue them before choosing. What a card adds still has to beat the map’s cost: see FE farming, counted after costs and tax. Hypocritical – Ember lists “1-1, 1-2 or 1-1” additional Embers on tlidb; the app’s own modifier text for the strongest strength reads “1 additional Ultimate Ember will drop when completing Netherrealm stages”, and the sixteen-FE reading is from that. Which Ember tier the other strengths add is not shown on tlidb.

Method and confidence

  1. The app’s own data was not used.
    A map’s result is dominated by its own cost and luck, and a card seen on 8 maps cannot be ranked against one seen on 5. No per-card income table exists in the app or in the community data.
  2. What a card adds times what it sells for.
    Card names and effects come from the tlidb Confusion Card Library; prices from the TLI Companion price feed (read 2026-11-10, rounded). This gives the tiers marked Data.
  3. Community sources.
    No public Confusion Card tier list was found. Two pages touch on the cards (see the sources below); neither ranks them. Everything not backed by step 2 is marked Opinion.
Historical measurements and price inputs
Confidence per tier
TierConfidence
SHigh for Beacon and Ember (price times drop size). Medium for Mist Essence and Queen’s Wick: they need that gameplay in the stage, and the Wick kind is not shown on tlidb.
DHigh: the drops sell for under 0.1 FE.
A, B, CLow to medium: Drop Quantity, Rarity and mini-game bonuses are judgements.

Still open: which Ember grade each Hypocritical – Ember strength adds, how often Distressed’s Queen’s Disciples drop a Beacon, and the market value of Divinity Slates, Hero Memories and Legendary gear (they vary too much to put one price on). Once enough runs carry a card, a per-card mean of map value minus cost, with a count, would replace the Opinion tiers.

Common mistakes

  • Reading the tier as fixed. Drop prices move, and an item that is S today drops a tier if it crashes.
  • Taking a “Hypocritical” card because its name is first in the list. Its Beacon and Ember versions are the best on this list and its Echo, Core and Fuel versions the worst.
  • Judging a card by its top strength. Most cards start at the weaker value; the Timemark decides which you see.

What changed

  • SS14 Tartarus (Oct 2026): the Confusion Cards of almost every past season were retuned. The card library on tlidb shows the SS14 values.
  • This list (2026-11-10): first version. It uses tlidb’s card library and the price feed of that day. Re-check after a price crash or a patch.

Sources

SourceDateUsed for
Confusion Card Library, tlidb.comundatedEvery card name and effect
Confusion Card, tlidb.comundatedHow cards are drawn: 4 attempts per card, 1 for Rainbow cards
Item prices, TLI Companion price feed2026-11-10FE prices of the drops, rounded
Torchlight: Infinite Season 13 Afterlight FE Farming Tier List, mmoexp.com2026-08-11Mystery Chests and extra Confusion Cards ranked highest when rerolling Residents’ Eye maps (SS13)
Comprehensive Guide: Three Stages of Farming the Netherrealm, TapTap (@Louispapa)2023-06-16Three Confusion Cards are drawn per round; it recommends no card by name

Recover from a misleading comparison

SymptomCheck and action
The high-tier reward did not appearCheck gameplay requirement, card variant, displayed strength and whether its drop is guaranteed or a chance.
The item price collapsedRevalue the added reward after tax and selling effort. The historical tier can change.
A monster card slows the mapInclude the extra time and danger before comparing FE per real hour.
There are no useful offersUse the least harmful compatible option. A weak offer is not a reason to buy an expensive setup just to activate it.

Next, write down the chosen card and reason, then check the completed map. One lucky or unlucky result does not measure the card’s long-run contribution.

How TLI Toolkit helps

  • The same list is in the app’s Guides page, with the prices shown live next to the drops.
  • The app records which Confusion Card a map carried (its modifier ids), so a per-card average from real runs can replace the Opinion tiers later.

Free for Windows 10 and 11: download TLI Toolkit. The cards come from the Netherrealm board; see also the Tartarus guide and the Followers guide.

Items in this guide

Try it in the app

It’s part of TLI Toolkit, free for Windows 10 and 11.

FreeWindows 10/11, no installWhat’s new

TLI Toolkit is a Windows PC app: open tlitoolkit.com on your PC to download it. The guides and strategies work on any screen.

Written from the game’s own texts, patch notes and community research. Mechanics change between seasons; if something here is out of date, tell us on GitHub.